Gödel's ontological proof - Quiz
  • 1. What does the symbol ◊ represent in modal logic?
A) It is possible that
B) For all x
C) It implies
D) It is necessary that
  • 2. What does the symbol ◻ represent in modal logic?
A) For some x
B) It is necessary that
C) The negation of
D) It is possible that
  • 3. What does the notation P(φ) represent?
A) Property φ is essential
B) Object x is God-like
C) Property φ exists necessarily
D) Property φ is positive
  • 4. According to Definition 1, what does it mean for an object x to be God-like?
A) x has only one essential property
B) x is a positive property
C) x exists in all possible worlds
D) x has all positive properties
  • 5. According to Axiom 2, the negation of a property φ is positive if and only if:
A) φ is positive
B) φ is not positive
C) φ is God-like
D) φ is essential
  • 6. What is defined as an essential property of an object x in Definition 2?
A) φ is a property x has in only one world
B) φ is a positive property
C) φ is the property of existence
D) x has φ and all ψ of x follow necessarily from φ
  • 7. How is 'necessary existence' defined in Definition 3?
A) The object is positive and necessary
B) The object has all positive properties in all worlds
C) Each essential property φ applies to some object in each possible world
D) The object exists only in the actual world
  • 8. What does Theorem 1 state about a positive property φ?
A) It is necessary that all objects have φ
B) It is impossible for any object to have φ
C) It is possible that there exists an object x having φ
D) The property φ must be God-like
  • 9. Which axiom states that being God-like is a positive property?
A) Axiom 3
B) Axiom 1
C) Axiom 5
D) Axiom 2
  • 10. What does Axiom 4 specify regarding positive properties?
A) If a property is positive, it is necessarily positive
B) Positive properties only exist in the actual world
C) If a property is positive, it cannot be essential
D) If a property is positive, it must be the negation of another
  • 11. What is the final conclusion of the argument (Theorem 4)?
A) It is necessarily true that a God-like object exists
B) It is possible that a God-like object exists
C) The existence of a God-like object is not provable
D) A God-like object exists only in the actual world
  • 12. What does the symbol ∀x represent?
A) There exists an x
B) For every x
C) Not x
D) It is possible that x
  • 13. Which axiom asserts that 'Necessary existence' is a positive property?
A) Axiom 5
B) Axiom 1
C) Axiom 3
D) Axiom 2
  • 14. Theorem 2 concludes that:
A) Being God-like is not a positive property
B) It is possible that there exists a God-like object x
C) A God-like object cannot exist
D) It is necessary that a God-like object exists
  • 15. Theorem 3 states that if x is God-like, then:
A) x exists in the actual world only
B) Every property of x is negative
C) x has no essential properties
D) Being God-like is an essential property of x
  • 16. What kind of logic does Gödel's ontological proof use?
A) Higher-order modal logic
B) Intuitionistic logic
C) First-order logic
D) Propositional logic
  • 17. What does Theorem 1 state about positive properties?
A) They are never exemplified
B) They are possibly exemplified
C) They are necessarily exemplified
D) They are only exemplified in our world
  • 18. Who is the mathematician that developed Gödel's ontological proof?
A) Gottfried Leibniz
B) Anselm of Canterbury
C) Kurt Gödel
D) Dana Scott
  • 19. Which philosopher provided the elaborate version of the ontological argument that Gödel specifically studied?
A) Immanuel Kant
B) Gottfried Leibniz
C) René Descartes
D) St. Anselm
  • 20. When did Gödel first create a version of the ontological proof?
A) 1987
B) Around 1941
C) 1978
D) 1970
  • 21. Who was allowed to copy Gödel's version of the proof in February 1970?
A) Dana Scott
B) Hao Wang
C) Oskar Morgenstern
D) Adele Gödel
  • 22. When was the ontological proof finally published?
A) 1978
B) 1970
C) 1987
D) 1941
  • 23. Whose philosophical views did Gödel say he followed in his religious belief?
A) Leibniz
B) Anselm
C) Spinoza
D) Kant
  • 24. What is the main focus of most criticism directed at Gödel's proof?
A) Its logical structure
B) Its axioms
C) Its conclusion
D) Its mathematical notation
  • 25. What is the primary implication of accepting the axioms in a logical proof?
A) The conclusion is proven true
B) The axioms become universally accepted
C) The conclusion follows logically
D) The premises are proven true
  • 26. Which philosopher suggested that Gödel might have welcomed modal collapse?
A) Graham Oppy
B) C. Anthony Anderson
C) Michael Gettings
D) Robert Koons
  • 27. Who presented suggested amendments to Gödel's proof that were later argued to be refutable?
A) Robert J. Spitzer
B) André Fuhrmann
C) C. Anthony Anderson
D) Jordan Howard Sobel
  • 28. Who agreed that the axioms might be questioned but disagreed with Oppy's counter-example?
A) Robert Koons
B) André Fuhrmann
C) Michael Gettings
D) C. Anthony Anderson
  • 29. What task does André Fuhrmann identify as necessary to determine which religion's god is proven?
A) A historical task
B) A linguistic task
C) A theological task
D) A mathematical task
  • 30. What happens if the axioms of a proof are doubted?
A) The conclusions can be doubted
B) The proof is automatically proven false
C) The conclusion is definitely false
D) The axioms become irrelevant
  • 31. Which of these is mentioned as a 'primitive' in Gödel's ontological axioms?
A) Essence
B) Necessity
C) Possibility
D) Contingency
  • 32. Who collaborated with Bruno Woltzenlogel Paleo to formalize Gödel's proof?
A) Dana Scott
B) Melvin Fitting
C) Christoph Benzmüller
D) Jordan Howard Sobel
  • 33. What inspired Benzmüller and Paleo's formalization effort?
A) The Archive of Formal Proofs
B) Sobel's 1987 argument
C) Melvin Fitting's book
D) Gödel's original manuscript
  • 34. Which scholar's 1987 argument was confirmed by the 2014 computational verification?
A) Benzmüller
B) Fitting
C) Scott
D) Sobel
  • 35. Which version of the argument were the researchers able to verify as consistent?
A) The 1987 Sobel version
B) The 2014 version
C) Melvin Fitting's reformulation
D) Gödel's 1970 manuscript
  • 36. Which proof assistant did Benzmüller and Scott use in 2025?
A) Isabelle
B) Coq
C) Lean
D) HOL Light
Created with That Quiz — a math test site for students of all grade levels.