The Great Transformation by Karl Polanyi
- 1. The Great Transformation by Karl Polanyi is a seminal work published in 1944 that explores the profound changes in human societies brought about by the rise of market economies and capitalism in the 19th century. Polanyi argues that the development of a self-regulating market system was not a natural evolution, but rather a historical transformation that led to significant social and economic upheavals. He emphasizes that the market, often portrayed as a natural entity, actually required complex social and political arrangements for its operation, which in turn necessitated a radical restructuring of societal values and institutions. Polanyi introduces the concept of the 'double movement', which describes the interplay between market expansion and social protection, illustrating how societies respond to the dislocation caused by market forces with movements aimed at re-embedding the economy within social relationships and ethical considerations. The book critiques the liberal economic thought of the time and highlights the potential dangers of unchecked market liberalism, making a compelling case for the importance of social and environmental safeguards against the commodification of land, labor, and money. Through his historical analysis, Polanyi provides critical insights into the relationship between economy and society, foreshadowing ongoing debates about economic systems, social justice, and the role of government in regulating markets in contemporary times.
What does Polanyi mean by the term 'fictitious commodities'?
A) Goods that are counterfeit or of inferior quality.
B) Financial derivatives and other complex modern financial instruments.
C) Goods that have only symbolic value and no real use.
D) Land, labor, and money, which are treated as if they were produced for sale.
- 2. What was the Speenhamland system?
A) A law that established minimum wage.
B) A system of poor relief that supplemented wages based on the price of bread.
C) A tax on imported grain.
D) An early form of trade unionism.
- 3. What does 'embeddedness' refer to in Polanyi's work?
A) The process of a country integrating into the global economy.
B) The idea that the economy is submerged in social relationships and institutions.
C) The idea that culture is rooted in economic base.
D) The psychological attachment people have to their possessions.
- 4. What role does the state play in the creation of a market society, per Polanyi?
A) The state is always the enemy of the market and tries to suppress it.
B) The state naturally withers away as the market takes over.
C) The state acts as a neutral referee between buyers and sellers.
D) The state is central to actively constructing and enforcing the market system.
- 5. How does Polanyi view the relationship between the market and nature?
A) The market allows humans to finally master and control nature completely.
B) Nature is irrelevant to the functioning of the economic system.
C) Treating nature (land) as a commodity leads to its ecological destruction.
D) The market is the best mechanism for the conservation of nature.
- 6. What is the ultimate result of the 'double movement'?
A) Strain and tension that leads to social crisis and potential transformation.
B) A perfect and stable balance between market and society.
C) The inevitable victory of the free market over protectionist forces.
D) The gradual disappearance of the nation-state.
- 7. What major 20th-century phenomenon does Polanyi link to the collapse of the 19th-century market system?
A) The discovery of nuclear energy.
B) The invention of the computer.
C) The decline of organized religion.
D) The rise of fascism and totalitarianism.
- 8. How does Polanyi's analysis differ from a orthodox Marxist analysis?
A) He argues that class conflict is irrelevant to history.
B) He focuses on the social catastrophe of markets, not just class exploitation.
C) He agrees with Marx on all major points of economic theory.
D) He believes the superstructure determines the economic base.
|