- 1. In 'Word and Object', published in 1960, the American philosopher Willard Van Orman Quine presents a groundbreaking exploration of language, meaning, and reference, fundamentally challenging the analytic and syntactic approaches to philosophy and semantics that dominated the field at the time. Quine argues against the notion of a clear distinction between analytic truths—statements that are true by virtue of meaning—and synthetic truths, which are contingent upon empirical observation. His famous thesis of the indeterminacy of translation posits that there is no unique, correct translation of statements between languages, suggesting that meaning is influenced by broader theoretical commitments and empirical contexts. Through meticulous analysis, Quine dismisses the idea that we can have a perfect understanding of reference and meaning in isolation, emphasizing instead the interconnectedness of beliefs and the web of language itself. Central to his argument is the challenge to logical positivism and the verification principle, advocating a naturalized epistemology that situates knowledge and its justification within the empirical sciences. 'Word and Object' is not merely a pivotal work in 20th-century philosophy but also a rich and complex text that invites readers to reconsider the foundations of how we communicate and understand the world.
What is the central problem explored in 'Word and Object'?
A) The nature of mathematical objects
B) The philosophy of time
C) Ethical relativism
D) The indeterminacy of translation
- 2. According to Quine, what can we never fully determine about 'gavagai'?
A) How to pronounce it correctly
B) Whether it refers to rabbit, rabbit stage, or rabbit part
C) Whether natives are lying about its meaning
D) What language it comes from
- 3. Quine argues that meaning is ultimately determined by:
A) Private mental states
B) Divine revelation
C) Universal grammar
D) Behavioral dispositions and stimulus meaning
- 4. Quine's philosophy is often described as a form of:
A) Absolute relativism
B) Transcendental idealism
C) Cartesian dualism
D) Naturalized epistemology
- 5. Quine's famous slogan 'To be is to be the value of a variable' concerns:
A) Ontology
B) Aesthetics
C) Psychology
D) Ethics
- 6. Quine is critical of which notion in traditional philosophy?
A) The value of logical analysis
B) The idea of meaning as mental entities
C) The existence of physical objects
D) The importance of science
- 7. What methodological approach does Quine advocate?
A) Phenomenological reduction
B) Theological investigation
C) Artistic interpretation
D) Scientific naturalism
- 8. Quine's view on the relationship between philosophy and science is that:
A) They are completely separate disciplines
B) Philosophy is continuous with science
C) Science has replaced philosophy
D) Philosophy is superior to science
- 9. Quine's position on modal logic (logic of necessity and possibility) is that:
A) It perfectly captures metaphysical truth
B) It is the foundation of all philosophy
C) It should replace classical logic
D) It is problematic due to referential opacity
- 10. Quine argues that the unit of empirical significance is:
A) Individual words
B) The whole of science
C) Mathematical formulas
D) Single sentences in isolation
- 11. What does Quine mean by 'semantic ascent'?
A) Shifting from talking about objects to talking about words
B) Speaking in a higher pitch
C) The historical development of language
D) Improving one's vocabulary
- 12. Quine's criticism of the 'myth of the museum' targets:
A) The value of museum collections
B) The idea that meanings are mental objects
C) The theory of evolution
D) Historical preservation efforts
- 13. According to Quine, what is the relationship between meaning and reference?
A) Reference is more important than meaning
B) Meaning determines reference completely
C) Meaning cannot be reduced to reference
D) Meaning and reference are identical
- 14. Quine's thought experiment about radical translation involves which imaginary people?
A) The ancient Greeks
B) The Martians
C) The Gavagai
D) The Turing test subjects
- 15. What philosophical doctrine does Quine attack in 'Two Dogmas of Empiricism'?
A) Dualism
B) Pragmatism
C) Reductionism
D) Materialism
|